CQ Guide: Why do businesses prefer RCA to traditional investigations?

When a quality issue arises, businesses can address the symptoms of the problem by fixing it, or they can take a more proactive approach to identify and remove the root cause of the problem. Businesses can use tools such as Root Cause Analysis (RCA) to prevent it from happening again and improve their processes in the long term.

Traditional Investigations vs. RCA

Traditional investigations and root cause analysis (RCA) are often used to identify the underlying causes of problems or incidents that have occurred.

Traditional investigations involve a systematic review of the events that led up to a problem or incident and typically involved collecting and analyzing data, interviewing witnesses, and reviewing documentation. A traditional investigation aims to determine what happened and why and to identify any immediate corrective actions that need to be taken.

Root cause analysis, on the other hand, is a more comprehensive approach that aims to identify the underlying causes of a problem or incident rather than just the immediate causes. RCA aims to identify and address the root causes of the problem or incident to prevent it from happening again. RCA systematically examines all factors contributing to the problem or incident, including organizational, technical, and human factors.

Both traditional investigations and RCA can be useful tools for identifying and addressing problems and incidents, but they differ in scope and focus. Traditional investigations are typically more focused on identifying immediate corrective actions, while RCA focuses on identifying and addressing the root causes of problems and incidents.

Conducting a successful RCA

To conduct an RCA, businesses require careful planning, effective communication, and a systematic approach to gathering and analyzing data. Here are some tips for conducting a successful RCA to ensure a comprehensive investigation approach:

  • Define the problem or issue you are trying to solve. This will help you focus your efforts and ensure that you are addressing the root cause of the problem.
  • Gather data about the problem, including information about when and where the problem occurs, who is affected by the problem, and any relevant circumstances or conditions.
  • Employ the right people with proper knowledge about the problem and the processes or systems involved. This could include team members, managers, or subject matter experts.
  • Follow a structured approach, such as the 5 Whys or the Fishbone Diagram, to help identify the root causes of the problem.
  • Prioritize potential root causes after identifying potential root causes based on their likelihood and impact.
  • Develop and implement solutions that address the root causes of the problem. Also, make sure to track the results of the solutions to ensure that they are effective.
  • Document and communicate the results of the RCA and share them with relevant stakeholders. This will help ensure that the problem is permanently resolved and that the root causes are prevented from occurring again.

Different Techniques for RCA

Several different techniques can be used to perform RCA. One of the popular approaches is the 5 Why technique which involves asking “why” five times in a row to drill down to the root cause of a problem. Other techniques are detailed below.

  • The fishbone diagram: This is also called a cause and effect diagram. This visual tool is used to identify a problem’s potential causes. It is called a “fishbone” diagram because the main cause is written at the head of the diagram, and the potential causes branch out like bones from the spine. Fault tree analysis is a graphical representation of a system’s logical relationships between failure modes. It is used to identify the likelihood and consequences of potential failures and to prioritize risk reduction efforts.
  • Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA): Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) is a risk management tool to identify and prioritize potential failures in a system or process. It helps to identify the root causes of potential failures and the potential effects of those failures on the system or process. By identifying and analyzing potential failure modes, organizations can take preventive measures to reduce the likelihood of those failures occurring and mitigate the potential consequences if they do occur.
  • Pareto Charts: A Pareto chart, named after Vilfredo Pareto, an Italian economist, is a bar chart used to display the relative importance of different factors or causes. Pareto charts are often used to identify the most important factors in a process or system and to prioritize efforts to improve the process or system.
  • Scatter Plot Diagram: A scatter plot is a diagram that displays data points as a collection of points on a two-dimensional graph. Scatter plots are useful for exploring and visualizing data, but they are not meant to make predictions or draw conclusions about cause and effect. You would need to use other statistical techniques, such as regression analysis.

Choosing the right technique for the problem or issue being addressed is important, as each technique has its strengths and limitations.

To transform your safety program from corrective to preventative, do the following:

  • Identify the current state of the safety program, including any areas that need improvement.
  • Determine the goals and objectives of the safety program and what you want to achieve through the transformation process.
  • Develop a plan for implementing changes to the safety program, including identifying the resources and support needed to make those changes.
  • Communicate the changes to all employees and stakeholders, and ensure everyone knows their responsibilities and the new procedures.
  • Train employees on the new safety procedures and provide ongoing support and reinforcement to ensure they are followed consistently.
  • Monitor the safety program’s effectiveness, and adjust as needed to ensure that it meets its goals and objectives.

ComplianceQuest hosted a webinar on "How to use Root Cause Analysis to Transform Your Safety Program." This webinar discusses the most effective RCA techniques and how you can practically apply them to ensure a comprehensive investigation approach.

cta guide rca

In Need of Smarter Ways Forward? Get in Touch.

Get a Demo Today
spinner
Request Demo